Views: 259 Author: Weishi Sheets Publish Time: 2026-11-21 Origin: Site
Content Menu
● G10 vs FR4: What Changes When You Specify the Laminate?
>> When a UL 94 V-0 Rating Is Required
● How to Compare G10 and FR4 Dielectric Strength Data
>> Match the Test Conditions Before Comparing the Numbers
>> Do Not Convert a Coupon Result Into a Part Voltage Rating
● Dry-Type vs Liquid-Filled Transformers: What to Check First
>> Dry-Type Example: A Machined Phase Barrier
>> Liquid-Filled Example: A Spacer in Contact With Insulating Fluid
>> Check Thermal Endurance Separately From Flame Performance
● From RFQ to First Article: A Transformer Laminate Checklist
● Request a Grade Review and Machining Quote
>> Can FR4 replace G10 in an existing transformer design?
>> Is G10 dielectric strength higher than FR4 dielectric strength?
>> Does a thicker FR4 sheet always improve transformer insulation?
>> Is FR4 suitable for oil-filled transformers?
>> Is G11 a better choice for elevated temperatures?
>> What should I request with a production shipment?
When comparing G10 vs FR4 for high-voltage transformer insulation, start with the component specification, not a generic ranking of the two materials. Both are rigid, woven glass–epoxy laminates that can be evaluated for machined barriers, spacers and supports. FR4 is the natural starting point when the drawing calls for flame-retardant laminate. G10 is a candidate when flame retardancy is not required and the proposed grade can meet the electrical, thermal and mechanical requirements. Neither designation establishes the voltage a finished part can withstand.
The real decision is whether a specific laminate, machined to your drawing, will perform in its intended location. That means reviewing how the part is loaded, what it touches, how hot it gets and which insulation tests the transformer must pass.

G10 and FR4 both use woven glass reinforcement in an epoxy resin system. The glass fabric reinforces the sheet, while the cured resin binds the layers together. The clearest practical distinction is that FR4 is a flame-retardant grade. That distinction does not establish which supplier's laminate is stronger, more heat resistant or easier to machine.
| Selection factor | G10 epoxy glass laminate | FR4 epoxy glass laminate | What to verify |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flame performance | Do not assume it meets a specified flame class. | Consider it when the drawing calls for a flame-retardant grade. | Exact product designation and documented rating at the applicable thickness. |
| Electrical performance | Compare the proposed grade against the part requirements. | Apply the same criteria; the flame-retardant designation does not establish electrical superiority. | Test method, specimen thickness, direction, conditioning and acceptance limits. |
| Thermal endurance | Do not assign a service temperature from the grade name. | Do not treat a flame classification as a thermal rating. | Long-term thermal evidence and compatibility with the transformer's insulation system. |
| Mechanical performance | Evaluate actual loading and reinforcement direction. | Evaluate those same conditions rather than assuming a trade-off for flame retardancy. | Flexural, compressive or other relevant properties, plus finished-part tolerances. |
If the drawing specifies UL 94 V-0, ask for documentation covering the exact laminate and the thickness relevant to the finished component. If a recess leaves a section thinner than the nominal sheet, flag it for review rather than assuming the rating for the starting stock covers the finished geometry.
V-0 describes specimen behavior in a controlled, small-scale vertical burning test. It does not mean the laminate is noncombustible, establish a continuous service temperature or demonstrate the fire performance of the complete transformer.
Dielectric strength describes how much electric stress a specimen withstands before breakdown under a specified test. It is commonly reported in kV/mm. Breakdown voltage, reported in kV, is the voltage measured for a particular test setup. Two data sheets may show both values without using the same specimen thickness, electrode arrangement or conditioning.
Consider two published commercial grades. The NP510A FR4 bulletin reports an electric strength of 25 kV/mm on a 1.59 mm specimen and a breakdown voltage of 65 kV on a 3.18 mm specimen. The NP500A G10 bulletin uses an ASTM test method for its electrical figures, whereas the FR4 bulletin reports an IEC method. These entries are useful for screening, but they are not a controlled comparison and should not be used to rank the two grades. They are also not guaranteed properties of material supplied by Guangdong Weishi.
Before comparing options, ask for results that match on these points:
- Test method, revision and electrode arrangement.
- Specimen thickness and test direction relative to the laminate layers.
- Conditioning before testing, especially exposure to humidity or water.
- Whether each value is typical, a specification minimum or a measured result for the shipment.
Multiplying 25 kV/mm by a 3 mm finished thickness gives an arithmetic result of 75 kV, not a 75 kV rating for the part. A machined barrier has edges, holes and interfaces that the test coupon does not represent. The relevant discharge path may be through the laminate, across its surface or through the surrounding medium.
The transformer design team must assess clearance, the shortest distance through air, and creepage, the shortest path along an insulating surface, wherever they apply. It must also establish which dielectric tests apply to the transformer and its specified insulation level. A laminate report cannot replace that verification.

Suppose a dry-type transformer needs a machined phase barrier, and the drawing requires V-0. Begin with documented FR4 candidates. Then review the smallest finished section, the position of the mounting holes, the edges facing energized hardware and the surface path between conductors. If a hole pattern changes during prototyping, do not assume the original electrical review still applies.
Where partial discharge is a concern, evaluate the installed geometry and the applicable test requirements. Partial discharge is a localized electrical discharge that does not completely bridge the insulation between conductors. A small air gap at an interface or a region of concentrated electrical stress can matter even when the laminate itself has a high coupon breakdown value. No generic G10 or FR4 designation establishes the discharge performance of the assembled barrier.
For a spacer exposed to insulating liquid, start with the exact fluid and the exposure conditions. Specify whether the component will contact petroleum-derived mineral oil, a natural or synthetic ester, or another fluid. Do not transfer a compatibility result from one fluid to another without evidence that it applies.
A useful review looks in both directions: what the liquid does to the laminate and what the laminate does to the liquid. For petroleum-derived insulating oil, a compatibility screen may assess changes in the oil's electrical or chemical properties as well as swelling, discoloration or other physical changes in the specimen. A passing screening result is not, by itself, full qualification for the transformer.
Glass transition temperature, or Tg, identifies the temperature region where the resin's behavior changes. It is not a continuous operating limit. Likewise, a thermal rating for a laminate does not automatically assign a thermal class to the complete insulation system.
Give the supplier the expected temperature at the part location and identify the adjacent materials, such as varnish, adhesives or insulating fluid. If thermal endurance drives the decision, ask for evidence relevant to the proposed grade and environment. A higher Tg or a switch to another glass–epoxy grade is a reason to review the evidence, not a substitute for it.

A useful quotation states what the supplier will deliver, what it can document and what the transformer manufacturer still needs to validate. Use these five steps to avoid comparing quotes for parts that are nominally similar but technically different.
1. Define the part's job. Identify whether it is a phase barrier, structural support, clamping spacer or another component. State whether it is dry, immersed or intermittently exposed to fluid, and identify the features that matter to its electrical or mechanical function.
2. Send a controlled drawing. Include the revision, finished thickness, tolerances, hole positions, recess depths and edge requirements. Specify reinforcement orientation where it matters to the load path. Mark dimensions that affect fit or insulation distances.
3. Request grade-specific evidence. Ask for the proposed laminate designation, technical data sheet, required flame documentation and electrical or thermal test data. For critical properties, distinguish guaranteed acceptance limits from typical catalog values.
4. Inspect a first article. A first article is an initial production-representative part. Check its dimensions and look for burrs, chipped edges, exposed fibers or delamination against agreed inspection criteria. Trial-fit it with the actual hardware so assembly issues are visible before volume production.
5. Control production changes. Agree on lot traceability, inspection records and notification before changes to the grade, source or manufacturing process that could affect performance. Route substitutions through engineering review instead of approving them on price or availability alone.
For meaningful quote comparisons, use the same drawing, inspection plan and document requirements with each supplier. Compare the price of conforming finished parts, not just the sheet price. A lower material quote is not a saving if it excludes first-article inspection or the evidence your approval process requires.

Guangdong Weishi New Materials Co., Ltd. develops, manufactures and supplies epoxy glass laminates, including FR4, G10 and G11, and offers custom machining. For a grade review and machining quote, send your drawing, target quantity, transformer type, operating environment and required test documentation. If you are evaluating a replacement, include the existing approved grade and the reason for the change. This lets the team address material availability, manufacturing feasibility and documentation against the same requirements before you order samples.
Only after engineering approval. Compare the exact grades for electrical behavior, mechanical properties, thermal endurance, fluid exposure and dimensional fit. A replacement that meets the flame requirement can still change how the finished part behaves under load or in service.
Not as a general rule. Compare commercial grades tested under equivalent methods, thicknesses, directions and conditioning. If that data is unavailable, request a matched test rather than selecting a winner from unrelated data sheets.
No. Extra thickness may help where the critical path is through the material, but it may do little for a path around an edge or through an adjacent air gap. A thicker part can also change the available space around hardware. Review the actual geometry before changing the drawing.
A specific FR4 grade may be a candidate, but the grade name does not establish oil compatibility. Request evidence for the exact laminate and fluid, then confirm the component meets the transformer manufacturer's qualification requirements.
G11 is worth evaluating when retaining properties at elevated temperature is important. Compare the proposed grade's documented thermal endurance and mechanical performance at the relevant temperature. If flame performance is mandatory, verify it separately rather than assuming it from the G11 designation.
Ask for the agreed grade and lot identification, a certificate of conformity if required, and whichever dimensional reports or test records the purchase specification calls for. Define those documents at the quotation stage so the delivered records can be matched to the parts you receive.
1.J&Q, [Compare G10 vs FR4 for High-Voltage Transformer Insulation] — original article and starting point for the comparison.
2.Norplex-Micarta, [NP500A Technical Data Bulletin] — commercial G10 example; ASTM test entries and distinction between typical and specification values. [norplex-micarta]
3.Norplex-Micarta, [NP510A IEC Technical Data Bulletin] — commercial FR4 example; reported electric strength, breakdown voltage and specimen thicknesses. [norplex-micarta]
4.UL Solutions, [Combustion (Fire) Tests for Plastics] — scope and criteria of small-scale flammability tests, including the UL 94 vertical test. [ul]
5.International Electrotechnical Commission, [IEC 60076-3:2013+AMD1:2018 — Power transformers: Insulation levels, dielectric tests and external clearances in air] — transformer-level insulation requirements and dielectric test framework. [webstore.iec]
6.ANSI, [IEC 60085 Ed. 4.0 b:2007 — Electrical Insulation] — distinction between thermal classification of insulating materials and insulation systems. [blog.ansi]
7.ASTM International, [ASTM D3455 — Compatibility of Construction Material with Electrical Insulating Oil of Petroleum Origin] — scope of mineral-oil compatibility screening and limits of a passing result. [store.astm]
content is empty!